Tubing mascaras wrap individual lashes in water-resistant polymers that form flexible tubes, preventing smudging and flaking while removing easily with warm water. Cosmopolitan editors tested multiple formulas and identified seven standouts.

Maybelline's Liquid Lash Extensions, called "the pioneer of tubing mascaras" by professional makeup artist Brittany Whitfield, delivers length without smudging in high heat and comes in eight shades from black to ivy green. A Cosmo contributing beauty editor praised it as "completely flake and smudge-free" and ranked it in her top three mascaras of all time.

Merit's Clean Volume mascara offers a softer, no-makeup makeup look that lasts 12 plus hours. A Cosmo beauty editor noted the formula coats every lash without clumping and holds a curl for hours.

Caliray's tubing mascara resists high humidity and delivers length without flaking throughout the day, according to testing. Tarte's Tartelette Tubing Mascara uses micro-tubing polymers and nourishes lashes while providing volume and length. A Cosmo commerce editor reported it never smudges and doesn't shed flakes mid-day.

CoverGirl's tubing mascara lasts 30 hours and separates each lash without clumping. A Cosmo beauty director tested it during Peloton workouts and found it withstood heavy sweating without budging or irritating sensitive eyes.

Lancôme's lash primer mascara includes a conditioning primer on one end and volumizing pigment on the other, marketed for dramatic thickness.

Tubing mascara is less likely to damage lashes than regular mascara because it removes easily with water alone, according to Whitfield. "The fibers literally crumble right off," she said, requiring no rubbing or oil-based removers.